"The Great Divorce" and the Challenge of Faith
Just a note to let you all know about a new essay of mine that's up today on Catholic Exchange entitled The Great Divorce and the Challenge of Faith (click on the title to go there). It's a meditation on faith and our heavenly destiny, based on C.S. Lewis' The Great Divorce with insights from Fr. Luigi Giussani's new book Is It Possible to Live This Way?
This sometimes happens when you read two books at the same time - ideas can collide in an amazing way!
Here's a taste:
Enjoy!Fr. Giussani thus radically reorganizes the categories of the faith vs. reason debate. Since faith is the foundation of our knowledge about the world, faith is the most reasonable choice to make when evaluating the testimony of someone you know and trust — especially if the encounter is exceptional in some way. He continues: “From a rational point of view, it’s clear that if you become certain that another person knows what he or she is saying and doesn’t want to deceive, then logically you should trust, because if you don’t trust you go against yourself, against the judgment you formulated that that person knows what he or she says and doesn’t want to deceive you.”[v] For Lewis’ fellow bus travelers to the heavenly valley, faith is actually the most reasonable response to the extraordinary encounters they are having, but in denying and rejecting the new vision, the visitors are acting in a most tragically irrational, unreasonable way. The human bond of trust they had with their now Bright friend or loved one should have enabled them to trust the information they were receiving and to allow themselves to be led by that love and trust into the mountains. But alas — they could not overcome their pride, their bitterness, their greed — that is, their insistence that Heaven’s infinite glory conform to their finite conceptions. And they go against themselves.
Labels: faith, spirituality

4 Comments:
Thanks for posting this, Kathleen. I love, love, love the Great Divorce and have often meditated upon its many powerful images. Good job!
Sherry W
Hi Kathleen, quick question on "Is It Possible to Live This Way": Is the style different than other Giussani works? I ask that because 1. I heard this is a literal transcription of conversations he had with the young, and 2. I've found Giussani's style to be a barrier, despite the fact that I've gained so much from those of his books I've read, and from priests in the movement or influenced by it. I love Giussani's mini-narratives and images, but they come rather infrequently. More often I find Giussani to be dense abstract writing about how Christianity is not an abstraction!
-Ryan.
Hi Kathleen, thanks for your response! I think I will go ahead pick up "Is it Possible to Live This Way." -Ryan.
Hi Ryan - sorry for the delay in responding. I just now checked this comments thread after several days.
Yes, what you've heard is correct about "Is It Possible..." by Fr. Giussani. It's a transcription of weekly talks he gave to the Memores Domini, the consecrated lay order within the Communion & Liberation movement. I understand the difficulty that Fr. Giussani's prose in his other books can pose; there are some similarities in his writing and speaking styles, obviously, but hopefully you'll find this book smoother sailing. :)
Per the movement's methodology, I think the best to explore Fr. Giussani's thought is in conversation and in relationship with others, in order to bounce things back and forth to help them take shape in our minds and our lives. At least, that's what CL helps me with the most. And that's what happened to me in reading CS Lewis in conjunction with Giussani - it was like they were conversing about the subject of faith, and it helped me get a new perspective on it. (Reading Giussani aloud helps too.)
All the best to you!
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home