Preparing for Pentecost
For all of Lent and much of Easter season I was on the road giving parish missions across the country. I spoke about conversion, prayer, discipleship, and some of the struggles I have with each of those aspects of Christian life. In several places, I had people come up to me and ask for an appointment to talk about something that had happened in their life.
In each case, they told me about personal experiences of God's power that they had encountered, and how the experiences had changed their lives. In every case, they would preface their story with something like, "You'll probably think I'm crazy, but..." One young woman told me of having several experiences in which all of the surrounding noises, whether it was the sound of a crowd in the church vestibule or traffic noise simply stopped and she heard Jesus speak a few brief sentences of comfort or direction. Another fellow spoke of how God had made it possible for him to go on a mission trip to Jamaica with his wife, even though he really didn't want to go and had told her there were five conditions that had to be met before he'd accompany her there. God met all five conditions. Then, while giving a destitute man in a shelter a shave (while trying to stay as far away from the man as possible) he experienced the eyes of Christ looking at him with love, rather than the poor man's eyes. That completely changed his attitude towards the whole experience in Jamaica, and began a profound experience of conversion to Christ for him.
A friend of mine told me the other day that sometimes while he's praying and contemplating the events of his life the Holy Spirit shows him a connection between what he thought were random events and he is filled with joy and begins to laugh spontaneously and uncontrollably - and he loves it! I am convinced this same fellow has received infused knowledge from God; insights into the nature of God that I know from years of study that have been revealed to him in prayer.
These experiences are not unique. We read of similar experiences, as well as locutions, ecstasies, visions, etc. in the lives of the saints. But for some reason, we have come to believe they are rare and only for the select few - those destined to be saints.

All these people haven't told many others, or in some cases any other people, because they don't hear others speaking of such experiences. They may be afraid that people will not just think they're crazy, but that they think they're special, and that they're making a claim to be "holier than thou." Yet when we read the Acts of the Apostles, Luke describes all kinds of powerful spiritual experiences that lead many people to speak in tongues, to prophesy, to spontaneously and joyfully praise God. The Acts of the Apostles are filled with signs and wonders performed by the Holy Spirit through the apostles and others. These experiences of the Holy Spirit lead to the conversion of thousands of people in some cases. Often we can dismiss these stories as exaggerations, group hysteria, or events unique to the early Church and no longer to be expected.
Peter Herbeck, Vice President and Director of Missions of Renewal Ministries in Ann Arbor, MI, writes about our low expectations for these sorts of religious experiences and our reticence to trust them in his new book, "When the Spirit Comes in Power." He quotes Mary Healy, a contemporary scripture scholar and theologian, who writes, "generations of ordinary lay Catholics have imbibed the notion that the spiritual life is essentially one of moral striving and formulaic prayer, apart from any direct experiential contact with God and his saving deeds." Jesus promises his disciples in the Gospel of John's Last Supper discourse, ""If you love me, you will keep my commandments. And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate to be with you always, the Spirit of truth, which the world cannot accept, because it neither sees nor knows it. But you know it, because it remains with you, and will be in you. I will not leave you orphans; I will come to you." John 14:15-18. Yet we live as though orphaned when we do not ask for guidance from that same Spirit of truth that guided the apostles, St. Paul and all the saints. We live as orphans when we do not believe Jesus who promises to abide in those who love their neighbor and keep his commands.
Of course, the Lord is present to us in a most intimate way in the Blessed Sacrament, his Body and Blood which we receive at Mass. He is also present in the Scriptures, especially when proclaimed at Mass. He is present in the presbyters and bishops who act in persona Christi, and in his body, the Church. The Holy Spirit touches our lives through the charisms God has given to others for our benefit, and we encounter his power, provision and healing through the manifold charisms distributed among the faithful. But there are other forms of religious experience that we can, and I believe, should expect if we are open to them.
Luke Timothy Johnson defines religious experience as "a response to that which is perceived as ultimate, involving the whole person, characterized by a peculiar intensity, and issues in action." Notice the experience is a response to an encounter with someone or something that is recognized as ultimate - and for Christian religious experience that is Jesus Christ, the Alpha and Omega. The Lord is the initiator. The experience is not generated by person him or herself. Nor is the focus on the emotional experience, as powerful as it might be. Herbeck writes, "All the spiritual writers in the Catholic mystical tradition warn against an excessive focus on religious experience and the need to apply solid discernment when we encounter spiritual phenomena...Yet, despite their constant warning, the mystical writers understand that religious experience is a normal part of the Christian life. In fact, their warnings assume it." These experiences are so powerful because they involve the whole person: intellect, will, emotions, memory, body and soul. It is an experience that in many cases leaves the individual fumbling for words to describe it. And, perhaps most importantly, it leads to action.
Sometimes the action may be a changed life with a new interest in reading the Bible and studying the Church's teaching. It may mean a long-held vice is abandoned. Sometimes it may lead to the pursuit of a particular calling in life, as in the case of Sr. Mary Teresa, a Loretto sister teaching in a school for the children of the elites of Calcutta, who was insistently called by Jesus to don a sari and minister to the poorest of the poor.
Perhaps part of our problem is fear. In his inaugural homily, the Holy Father spoke openly and eloquently about this fear....
Are we not perhaps all afraid in some way? If we let Christ enter fully into our lives, if we open ourselves totally to him, are we not afraid that He might take something away from us? Are we not perhaps afraid to give up something significant, something unique, something that makes life so beautiful? Do we not then risk ending up diminished and deprived of our freedom?We may be afraid of what Jesus might ask of us, or, like the people I spoke to, wonder if people will think we are "Jesus freaks," liars, simple-minded enthusiasts, or addicts who've switched drugs of choice.
But what if during this week prior to Pentecost, we asked for an outpouring of the Spirit into our hearts? What if we took a careful moral inventory and examined where we are still selfish, and looked at what sins - however seemingly small - we still commit and have grown accustomed to? Do we really believe the Lord's promise to send an Advocate to be with us always? If so, always includes today, in your town, in your heart and mine. Let's stop underestimating God, and pray that the gifts given us in Confirmation may begin to bear fruit in our lives. May we believe that it is really possible for Jesus to abide in us and we in Him through the action of the Holy Spirit.

20 Comments:
"generations of ordinary lay Catholics have imbibed the notion that the spiritual life is essentially one of moral striving and formulaic prayer, apart from any direct experiential contact with God and his saving deeds."
You know, you keep generating this canard about previous generations of Catholics without any substantiation, just anecdotal evidence. When are you going to tire to disrespecting good Catholics you didn't even know? How do you know they existed totally on moral striving and formulaic prayer?
Mary Healy is a very well-educated and orthodox theologian who has contact with many, many lay people. I, too, have had lots of contact with laity - and clergy, for that matter - who in good faith have tried to live good, moral lives and have prayed as best they could. I count myself in that category, but I'm beginning to really believe the Lord may desire more for me - and more from me.
The point I'm trying to make is that the Lord is offering us more. If the kind of religious experience that I posted about is widespread, I would expect
a) to see the kind of thirst for holiness that I've witnessed in the people who have spoken to me about their experiences;
b) more people sharing their experiences with other people - when we experience something truly good, we naturally tend to want to tell others about it;
c) many more people in our parish adult formation classes, daily Mass, confession, bible studies, adoration and other devotional experiences;
d) more Catholics applying their faith and using their charisms in the marketplace.
The power of the Holy Spirit can change lives in supernatural ways. The early Church spread dramatically throughout the Roman Empire in spite of persecutions because people experienced God's saving power in ways that made it worth risking one's livelihood, reputation, and even one's life.
Well a lot of the testimony here seems to be bargaining with God, like "Meet all five of my conditions" and I'll do this or that. That's hardly being in the spirit.
Fr. Mike, your post speaks of my experience as well. During my period of entrance into full communion with the Church (about 15 years ago now), the Lord assisted me with many graces and helps that made me feel weird... until I was able to find trusted friends to share these experiences with. That freed me to be able to move in the direction of fruit that could mature and be shared, lived.
And by the way, to anonymous, I don't think we have to look to previous generations to find people who hold that Christianity equals moral striving without an encounter with Christ. I think this idea plagues all of us at one time or another.
Marie,
I didn't say that, Fr. Fones said it. I was saying it didn't characterize previous generations. Read the posts more carefully.
Good post. We've all had experiences like these, although because they are so personal, few people talk about them.
Regards
I think that one thing your post points out Fr. Mike is the need for spiritual direction
dramatically tied with discipleship! What you are pointing out is very much what the famous theologian Fr. Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P highlighted in many of his books.
Bobby
As we call forth the Holy Spirit, maybe our boldness in sharing our stories will be increased. Thanks for sharing these with us, Fr. Mike! Is anyone else praying the Pentecost novena, the original novena?
Come, Holy Spirit, fill the hearts of Your faithful, and enkindle in them the fire of Your love. AMEN
--Alisa
Perhaps because I come from an Igantian spiritual environment (I am a spirtiual director trained int he Ignatian tradition), the idea of people having religious experiences and talking about them is not a strange one to me. I have had some extraorindarily powerful experiences of God's presence and have listented to others describe theirs.
But I certainly agree that this is not the norm for many Catholics...which says something about how we are engaging in catechesis.
How about the following as a guideline for sharing a personal encounter with Jesus....
"People don't care about your experience until they experience that you care."
Does that summarize almost all of I Cor 12-14 or what?
Sure, some people will think you're crazy if you share your encounter.
So!? Some folks thought the first charismatics were drunk on new Pentecost wine. That didn't stop Peter from sharing the experiences of the apostles and disciples and linking them to the prophecy of Joel.
Being a teacher, a story-teller, a relater of experience, I like the quote from one of the popes in my memory:
Modern man listens more willingly to witnesses than to teachers, and, if he does listen to teachers, it is because they are witnesses. (P Paul VI Encyclical on Evangelization #41 )
Peace, .ed.
I think, in discussing this post, we should also keep these words of Fr. Mike in mind: "And, perhaps most importantly, [religious experience] leads to action."
That action cannot, of course, be limited to telling others about our experiences.
I wonder, though, if it's common for Christians to experience God's power but not be moved to action, because they think they must first discuss their experience with someone, and they're afraid to do that.
While "Preparing for Pentecost" please check out the info at the following link ... "Pentecost is..."
http://ccc.garg.com/index.php?name=PNphpBB2&file=viewtopic&p=6714#6714
Tom:
I think that how one responds to religious experience depends upon so many things:
how "clear" the experience is (say first mode in Ignatian discernment) , on whether or not is it a form of guidance to "do" something (sometimes it is just consolation for you and the response if simply grateful acceptance), where you are in your spiritual journey and how accustomed you are to recognizing and responding to prompting of the Holy Spirit, *if* you have someone in your life you can talk to about it, etc.
Those who are used to listening and obeying such promptings (actual graces) are more confident in following them - even if they can't talk about them first but that usually takes a history of positive experiences that gives you confidence (not presumption!) in the validity of the Holy Spirit working in such ways.
More common, I think, is people habitually ignoring or talking themselves out of paying attention in the first place.
Sherry:
To take your example of consolation for which the response is simply grateful acceptance, should not those who have been consoled go forth and console?
At the very least, one who has consolation lives differently, or should.
Tom:
You may be looking at this on the macro level and I on the micro level. (I used to teach classes in how to hear God's voice and was thinking of a given specific instance).
In general, of course, faith without works is dead and mysticism that doesn't result in obedience and charity toward others is unreal.
But not every "experiential" encounter with God must or should led to some specific action. Sometimes, the word is simply "rest" or "peace". Sometime the action to which one is called is to stop and wait - that we could actually hinder the purposes of God by bustling ahead.
But, of course, those sorts of concerns are usually for those who are well along in the way.
"Rest"? "Peace"?
What are you, a Carmelite?
Even then, an experienced Carmelite is a sign of restful peace (or possibly peaceful rest, I'm not altogether sure what La Madre was getting at) to the world.
Ah, the Dominican inquisition has caught up with me . . .
Even our rest or play can and will be used by God as an external grace for others - but we are still really resting!
You can go back to work now, Tom, while contemplating the eschatological perfection of our ultimate rest in union with God.
Thank you for the beautiful personal testimonies of experiencing God. He does want us to know Him, and I thank God that He has allowed me to hear His voice in so many ways.
Come Holy Spirit and pour out your annointing on every believer this Pentecost so that we may go forth healing the sick, raising the dead and casting out demons!
Sorry I didn't respond more quickly to some of these comments.
Here are a few quick responses, in chronological order:
1) "Well a lot of the testimony here seems to be bargaining with God, like "Meet all five of my conditions" and I'll do this or that. That's hardly being in the spirit."
I don't know to what you're referring, anonymous. Every Christian does have to fulfill their Christian role by praying both as an individual as well as part of a community of faith (pre-eminently in the liturgy), performing corporal and spiritual works of mercy, discerning one's vocation, etc. That will often be an act of will on our part, made possible by actual graces to which we are responding. Grace makes our response possible, not necessarily easy.
What I'm trying to remind folks is that the Holy Spirit has been given to us to transform us, and a life-changing experience of Jesus through the Holy Spirit is possible, and was apparently considered normative in the early Church. Such experiences appear over and over again in the writings of saints and mystics. My fear is we don't often ask for such experiences, even though Jesus himself tells us to!
"For everyone who asks, receives; and the one who seeks, finds; and to the one who knocks, the door will be opened. What father among you would hand his son a snake when he asks for a fish? Or hand him a scorpion when he asks for an egg? If you then, who are wicked, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will the Father in heaven give the holy Spirit to those who ask him?'" Lk 11:10-13
2) Bobby, you are right. Spiritual direction will be in more demand as we begin to ask for - and expect - guidance from the Holy Spirit.
3) Alisa, I am praying the Holy Spirit novena, thanks to my good friend, Daniel, who reminded me that it began last Friday. EWTN.com has one version here: http://www.ewtn.com/Devotionals/pentecost/seven.htm
4) Tom, it was Luke Timothy Johnson who indicated that religious experience results in action. I heartily agree - and even consolations such as Sherry was mentioning, e.g., the call to be at peace, while it may very well not issue in immediate action will, I would hope, change, even if slightly, the way I approach other people, my work, and my need to feel "in control."
Gotta run - my flight's about to board. Off to a Provincial Council meeting.
Post a Comment
<< Home