Raising the Dead and the Kingdom of God
It has happened throughout Christian history. St. Dominic raised a Roman boy from the dead in front of a number of highly intelligent witnesses, for instance. We have their testimony which has been preserved as part of his canonization process. It is the experience of the resurrection power of Jesus Christ breaking through at its fullest.
But here's a medically documented story from February 1, 2008 news story on Palm Beach, Florida television station WSVN. (Hat tip: Mark Shea)
A well-known, local cardiologist tells the story:
Jeff Markin: "I drove to the Garden's Hospital, went in, took out my wallet and fell on the floor with a massive heart attack."
For 40 minutes doctors and nurses in the ER tried to revive him. When they couldn't get his heart started again they called for Dr. Crandall, who was doing rounds in the hospital at the time.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "As I entered the ER it was like a war zone. Here was this lifeless body on a stretcher."
The doctor couldn't do anything and could only confirm what everyone already knew, Jeff was dead. He had gone almost an hour without a heartbeat, and his body was starting to decompose.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "His face, his arms, his legs were pitch black with death. I said, 'Let's just call the code, let's end it because there's no life left.'"
As Dr. Crandall turned to leave, he says he got another call this time, a call from God to pray.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "A voice told me to turn around and pray for that man. I looked down at the body, and I said, 'Lord, what can I pray for this man? He's gone.' All of a sudden these words came out, 'Father, I cry out for this man's soul, if he does not know, you raise him from the dead.'"
Despite protests from doctors and nurses who were preparing Jeff's body for the morgue, doctor Crandall insisted they shock him one more time.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "So that doctor came over with those paddles and blasted that man and, all of a sudden, instantly a perfect heartbeat came up on the monitor. The stomach started moving, the chest started moving. This man started breathing on his own, and I said, 'This man has been prayed for, he has been brought back from the dead by prayer in the name of Jesus.'"
snip.
He woke up to a second chance, one that can't be explained by medicine or science. As Dr. Crandall puts it, the only answer is divine intervention.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "You are speaking to a scientist, a cardiologist, someone who loves medicine. I've never, ever seen this. There are always people that do not believe these events, and I will just tell them that it did happen. It was a real story, a real life that was restored."
What is interesting is that Dr. Crandall also mentions in the interview that he routinely prays for his patients.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "If you come in with a problem into our service, we are definitely going to treat you with conventional medicine, but we are going to believe it too. We are going to attack it with conventional medicine, and we are going to attack it with prayer."
He calls himself the Christian physician because he prays with each heart patient he sees at his Palm Beach practice. The difference, he says, is dramatic.
Dr. Chauncey Crandall: "The reason I pray for people is because I found, early in my trained practice, that there were miracles, unexplained healings."
The healer with a charism of healing. We've heard these kinds of stories from other medical professionals who exercise their professional skill and the charism of healing together and who see astonishing clinical results that definitely transcend the clinical norm. And I've met priests who are used in this way, through the sacramental ministry and outside of it.
My brother, who is a chiropractor who seems to also have a charism of healing, has a remarkable tale, which I've told before in my series on Independent Christianity.
Last summer he accompanied a team of volunteers from his evangelical church to build a house in an extremely poor Indian village in southern Baja. My brother is an experienced chiropractor who has pioneered new techniques and traveled around the world teaching them. Gary was treating local people when a frail woman was brought in who had suffered from a serious and very painful dislocation of the elbow for 3 years. Gary hesitated. There was no way to obtain an x-ray. Treating such a neglected injury in a woman who was already fragile without proper diagnostic tools is very tricky and he was afraid that he would hurt her. As he struggled to decide what to do, a local Protestant pastor suggested that he pray. Gary did so, asking that the bones align themselves properly.
My brother said that the woman’s arm started to quiver and then, with a loud pop that was heard all over the room, the elbow slipped into place by itself. The woman had full strength almost immediately. The visiting team asked the woman to share her healing with the teen-agers on the trip so that they would know that they could expect great things from God. My brother joyfully summed it up this way: “The whole experience was what church should be like.”
I once did a gifts interview with a woman who had had a international healing ministry for 30 years and described the experience of seeing the dead raised. I, of course, tried to affect a calm, matter of fact professional air about the whole thing and asked simply. "Hmmm. Raising the dead? Can you describe what you did and what happened step by step?"
Dang if she didn't want to talk about it but really wanted to talk about something else. Bummer.
There is such a need for the healing ministry out there. If you are interested in getting some top notch training in this area, I'd like to suggest the Institute for Christian Ministries in Seattle. Founded by a Dominican friar, Fr. Leo, who lived in the same priory with Fr. Michael Sweeney at Blessed Sacrament parish in Seattle, ICM combines the best of professional pastoral care with a confidence in the supernatural power and love of God to heal. The Formation in Healing Ministry Program is a portable two year training that produces teams of three who pray in a direct and sustained way for those sick in body, heart, or spirit.
During my Seattle days, I interviewed dozens of ICM alumni and so I have some sense of the remarkable things that happen when they pray. Fr. Mike brought the Formation in Healing Ministry Program into the Newman center in Eugene when he was pastor and had a wonderful experience with it.
As Fr. Leo used to say " wherever God's love is present, healing occurs." This is one big incentive for discerning the charisms you have been given and for facilitating the discernment of others. All the charisms are healing in the broader sense because all of them make God's love present. And then some in our midst are given the specific, narrow gift of healing and restore life and hope to so many.
Luke 10:9: "Cure it those who are sick and say, The Kingdom of God is very near to you."

19 Comments:
Another healing ministry is run by Francis and Judith MacNutt in Jacksonville, Florida. They are very well respected in Charismatic circles, and offer their schools of healing prayer throughout the year in various locations. Francis MacNutt has also authored several books on healing. The one entitled simply "Healing" is what I would consider a definitive work on the subject.
For me, learning about the gifts of the Holy Spirit, and particularly the gift of healing, opened up a whole new dimension that greatly enriched my faith life, and deepened my love of Christ. It gives me great joy to lay hands on people to pray for their healing. And yes, sometimes miracles do happen!
Isn't the evaluation of the work of charisms pretty subjective though? There are a lot of healing on the televangelist shows and a lot of those are fakes.
Carole
The answer to the question "why?" are some healed and some are not lies in the fact that mankind was not created to live in the 'flesh' forever. ALL flesh dies...some sooner, some later.
The Bible is very clear that flesh and blood cannot inherit the Kingdom. There is physical DNA and spiritual DNA. To the caterpillar it's the end, to the butterfly it's the beginning.
Our birth and death are in God's hands...nothing is left to chance. Nothing can separate us from HIS love. Aren't you glad!
Rick:
I am sorry to hear about your sister. But you are right. Some of our questions in this life will be answered beyond our dreams. Some will only be answered in the next.
Catherine of Siena buried with her own hands several of her own nephews and nieces who had died of plague. But she was also used of God to heal several people dying of the plague - including her confessor and eventual biographer, Fr. Raymond de Capua.
'
Even those whom God uses in astonishing ways never come to the end of the agonizing questions or the need to trust God in darkness.
Well, my sister was holy and she died from cancer. So my question is still unanswered.
Rick
Hi Rick:
You have certainly asked the $800 billion dollar question.
I have some partial, provisional answers - no one has a cut-and-dried answer because it is really the old "why does God allow evil" question.
A few things that those heavily involved in the healing ministry know:
1) God seems to have chosen not to enter this world unilaterally. By that I mean that he seems to have limited himself to entering this world through the assent and cooperation of a human being - whether through Jesus of Nazareth or (of course, in total dependence upon Christ's unique redeeming work) through his mother, the communion of saints or a living Christian.
2)Therefore, intentional discipleship is key because charisms which we receive in baptism and the vocations for which we were annointed in baptism don't manifest until the point when our personal faith "releases" the sacramental graces that we have received. Everything start with "dropping the net" and following Christ in the midst of his Church.
3) The holier we become, the closer to Christ we become, the freer he is to use us - even in remarkable ways. The more we pray, the more expectant we are, the more amazing things we will see.
4) Charisms really, really matter. The charism of healing is being given to the baptized in significant (not huge) quantities but many don't know. Some are actually discouraged by priests. I know of one woman with an outstanding gift who was told by a priest to regard it as a spiritual temptation. Fortunately, she came to us and is now being mentored by a bishop and a number of people's lives have been changed dramatically through her charism - including people I know. There is a
lot at stake in taking seriously and fostering all the charisms God is sending us.
5) There is much more that God wishes to do through his Church but it won't happen until we start to live as disciples together and offer our charisms and live our vocations together. Even the most most holy and gifted of us are not big enough channels as individuals compared to what God can and will do through the Christian community as a whole.
6) Organized communal intercessory prayer for the spiritual renewal of our communities can change the spiritual atmosphere of a place, making points 1-5 much more frequently experienced.
7) Even those with a well developed charism still deal with the mystery of why some are not healed. Typically, they report that about 75% of those prayed for experience some kind of partial or progressive healing. Examples of total, instantaneous healing (like the woman in Baja that my brother prayed for) are relatively rare.
8) A question that one thoughtful priest asked: why doesn't God give more people the charism of healing? No one knows although its pretty obviously that the gift is more common that we tend to think it is. If our parishes were places where a general culture of discernment reigned and people were helped to *really* discern the breadth of charisms, I think we'd find charisms of healing in nearly every community.
Just some hasty thoughts. Hardly a definitive answer.
So why are some healed while others are not?
Rick
A very interesting discussion, but for the life of me I can't see what charisms have to do with healing miracles. It's also interesting that of all the reported healing miracles at Lourdes, only 67 have been definitively supported by the Vatican.
Carole
Carole:
Charisms are gifts given to us at baptism that enable us to be used by God as a channel of his love, mercy, beauty, truth, deliverance, or healing for someone else.
There is such a thing as a charism of healing given to ordinary Christians through whom God brings healing where it should not happen medically. And there are many other charisms -(intercessory prayer, encouragement, mercy, hospitality, etc - that have powerful healing impacts (in the broader sense) that can also be linked to physical healing.
The criteria of miracles at Lourdes is that of absolute complete spontaneous cures (so not partial or progressive) which are completely verifiable medically (all the records and tests have to be in existence and available) and, of course, linked directly to being dipped into the water at Lourdes (Most healings that occur in the Church are not related to Lourdes).
The man who came back to life in the ER in Florida would not count, for instance - although his medical records are available and there are lots of expert witnesses.
But the work of healing that God is doing in the world is much broader than that.
Rick,
I, too, am very sorry about your sister. My father died when he was 58 of lung cancer. A friend of his brought over the friend's pastor to pray for my Dad's healing. As they were praying for my father's healing, I had no doubt in my mind that he was not going to be physically healed. This wasn't a sign of my lack of faith or God lacking in goodness. Actually, it was a sign of the Lord's utter goodness because God had another healing in mind for him - his complete and total healing that can only be realized in seeing God!
Rick, if your sister was holy then she has been completely healed. No more pain, no more tears, eternal bliss in Infinite Love. The tough part is for us who are left behind. Remember, God never meant this life to be LIFE. The life he desires for us is perfect happiness by being perfectly united to him in perfect love in heaven.
I will be praying for you...
Francis MacNutt, on page 193 ff of his book, "HEALING" lists twelve possible reasons why some people are NOT healed. An earlier version of the same topic is available at
http://www.christianhealingmin.org/newsletter/1991/themystery.htm
Francis MacNutt will be giving a course on the gift of healing for the International Catholic Charismatic Renewal Service See http://www.iccrs.org/
and for lots of reading material, see: http://www.christianhealingmin.org/newsletter/issues.htm
Peace,
Carole;
Part of the criteria for the cures mentioned from Lourdes, or the resuscitation of Mr. Markey in Florida is that the results go beyond medical explanation. In the case of Mr. Markey, the objective, physical evidence said that he was dead.
In the case of healings happening through the charisms of healing or intercessory prayer, the results are either significantly beyond the clinical norm for healing (that is, more rapid, or more substantial than would normally be expected) or they happen when no healing is expected. For example, the husband of a teacher for the Institute had pancreatic cancer. Now overall, fewer than 5% of all patients are still alive 5 years after initial diagnosis. The collective median survival time of all patients is 4-6 months. Someone known by the Institute with the charism of healing prayed with him (over the phone!), and he now has no signs of the disease.
In general, I would say many Catholics have low expectations for what God may do in the world, and consequently, we may not ask often enough for God to intervene. But even when we do, we have to always add, as did Jesus in Gethsemane, "but not my will, but Your will be done."
I think too that there is a distinction between healings and miracles. Not all healings are miracles. As the church is very selective of a miracle as in the case within a canonization process.
As Fr. Mike said we tend not to expect extraordinary things from God, as a result, when a healing takes places we tend to call it a miracle when in fact it can simply be a healing.
Just some thoughts.
Bobby
"Entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem>
William of Ockham
Actually, 2 of the 3 signs of a charism are objective. As I say in every workshop I teach "If you have a charism of healing, people get well, If they are worse off after you are done, its a clue.!" (sound the laugh track at this point)
Charisms are not what we announce about ourselves -or fantasize about ourselves. They are REAL. God really enters the world of time and space through his people and changes it. That's why they have to be discerned in the midst of the Christian community who can certainly tell whether or not you have a charism of encouragement or healing or teaching or music.
Charisms do what they are supposed to do. If you have a charism of teaching, people *learn* etc. If they aren't learning, you need to take that as an counter-indication. That's how I figured how that God does not use me in the healing ministry. There was no sign that people got well.
That's why we always emphasize, it is success to know where you are not gifted.
Sleezeballs televangelists say nothing about whether or not *this* person is actually used by God in *this* specific way on an on-going basis.
I think charisms such as those of teaching or administration can be objective (you fit where you fit, after all), but when you get into the healing area it gets quite subjective or at least non-verifiable. In the examples that were cited above, there's no real way to prove that healing charisms were at work versus whether the medical treatments had finally kicked in.
Carole
I believe I am being led to seek urgent prayer for my cousin's husband Roy in Bolivia who suffered a stroke and is a vegetative coma. I believe God wants to do a miracle here, and I am asking you all to please join me in prayer to this end. Pray for his family, especially his wife who believes God is going to do a miracle. Pray that she is able to pray with authority over him. This form of prayer is new to her, but I was able to instruct her to pray. I also sent them this website address below of a man in Florida who was raised from dead to encourage her faith. I believe God wanted to call yesterday and proclaim a miracle over him, but I didn't know at the time that she was believing for one and I chickened out because I thought they would think I was crazy. I now know that He did want me to call, but I was dull to His voice and I have repented and ask that you would join me in hearing His voice for this miracle. To Our Lord Jesus be all the Glory! Thank you, Dorothy Dodson
----- Forwarded Message ----
Subject: FW: FW: Florida man raised from the dead
Porfavor hagan esto lluegar a Chiquina y familia.
Yo si creo en milagros…y he atendido conferencias que tan testificado de grandes milagros. Cuand recibi la noticia de Roy, a lo que me puse a orar, senti el deseo de llamar a Bolivia, pedirles que pongan el telefono al oido de Roy y orarar por que se recupere, pero le dije a Dios que necesitaba escuchar lo mas claro si era su voluntad, porque pense que seria muy duro hacerlo y que pensarian que soy loca y tambien que estoy siendo demasiodo insensitiva con usted cuando estan pasando por tanto dolor asi que no lo hice. Pero me senti mal en no hacerlo, y cuando llame a una amiga para orar con ella hacerca de esto porque ella tiene mucha fe, ella me trato de animar a hacerlo, pero yo no me acobarde. Ahora que escucho que ustedes buscan un milagro, les cuento esto para que sepan que yo si creo que es la voluntad de Dios que Roy se recupere y que senti esto cuando oraba, y les mando el video en el email debajo para animarlos y les prometo llamar a todos los grupos que consoco que creen en milagros y pedirles por uno y yo tambien estare pidiendo lo mismo.
Con todo mi corazon - Doroti
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: Mike Dodson [mailto:dmdodson@gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, February 25, 2008 12:18 PM
To: Dorothy M Dodson; jp.pontbriand@comcast.net; Joe Fetters; Sean Jones
Subject: Fwd: FW: Florida man raised from the dead
Hey guys,
How about this. Watch the video about a man raised from the dead.
Mike
---------- Forwarded message ------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Date: Mon, 25 Feb 2008 06:15:06 -0800
From: georgialamothe@sbcglobal.net
Subject: Fwd: Florida man raised from the dead
To: georgialamothe@sbcglobal.net
Date: Mon, 25 Feb 2008 01:16:29 +0000
http://www1.wsvn.com/features/articles/specialreport/MI75423
Click on this link - then click " watch the video"
Rick,
I am so sorry for your loss. So many times God does not answer our calls for restored health. Miracles are few and far between it seems. God is, however, always present bringing people courage, patience, emotional strength. At times the "gift" is the visitor who makes a difficult moment bearable. I have worked hospice, home care and now visit through a hospital ministry. I have seen people healed and watched others die. May the intensity of your pain lessen with time.
The Bible indicates raising the dead to be easy, the disciples just did it.. no fuss. I find it just as easy.
Am happy to talk with the interested.
John - Norfolk - England
john.smith2000@tiscali.co.uk
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home