Friday, July 6, 2007

Gospel Riches & Globalization

A fascinating article in Christianity Today about the globalization of American inspired prosperity gospel in Africa.

"prosperity-tinged Pentecostalism is growing faster not just than other strands of Christianity, but than all religious groups, including Islam. Of Africa's 890 million people, 147 million are now "renewalists" (a term that includes both Pentecostals and charismatics), according to a 2006 Pew Forum on Religion and Public life study. They make up more than a fourth of Nigeria's population, more than a third of South Africa's, and a whopping 56 percent of Kenya's.

Cars in many African cities display bumper stickers like "Unstoppable Achiever," "With Jesus I Will Always Win," and "Your Success Is Determined by Your Faith," says University of London professor Paul Gifford in his 2004 book New Christianity: Pentecostalism in a Globalising African Economy. Gifford notes how these renewalists move beyond traditional Pentecostal practices of speaking in tongues, prophesying, and healing to the belief that God will provide money, cars, houses, and even spouses in response to believers' faith—if not immediately, then soon.

In its 2006 survey, Pew asked participants if God would "grant material prosperity to all believers who have enough faith." Eighty-five percent of Kenyan Pentecostals, 90 percent of South African Pentecostals, and 95 percent of Nigerian Pentecostals said yes. Similarly, when Pew asked if religious faith was "very important to economic success," about 9 out of 10 Kenyan, Nigerian, and South African renewalists said it was."


Snip.

Allan H. Anderson, professor of Global Pentecostal Studies at the University of Birmingham, says African renewalists are, indeed, eclipsing denominationally based churches and missions. "The older churches," he says, "are struggling to keep up with the jet-setting entrepreneurs who head up these new organizations."

"If you're not willing to play that [prosperity] game," says Vince Bacote, associate professor of theology at Wheaton College, "get ready to get steamrolled."


Snip

Why is this happening? A confluence between traditional African values and American lifestyles. And the staggering global reach of evangelical media.

"As Pentecostal-charismatic programming has flooded Africa, renewalist numbers have risen from 17 million in 1970 to 147 million in 2005. The continent's largest religious broadcaster is Santa Ana, California–based Trinity Broadcasting Network (TBN), followed by Europe's GOD TV.

As TV sets grow common in African cities, these broadcasters are gaining huge audiences. People who lack a TV often watch with neighbors, and viewing options are limited. In Zambia, only three stations click on: MUVI TZ, which airs reruns of U.S. shows and old movies; ZNBC, the Zambian National Broadcasting Company; and TBN. Television is becoming the continent's religious classroom.

"People turn it on and assume that TBN is American Christianity, and Americans know everything, so why not listen to it?" says Bonnie Dolan, founder and director of Zambia's Center for Christian Missions, a Reformed school for pastors. "[W]e have Zambians looking to the West for direction, and they associate TBN with the West. And it's killing our churches."


Since TBN has always given me the creeps, its hard to grasp its fascination for people from other cultures. But I know that CT is describing a reality we need to grapple with.

When we were in Indonesia, we discovered that most fervent Indonesian Catholics had attended the evangelistic crusades of American Pentecostal preachers like Benny Hinn. They sang (in two languages and with a beautifully dressed choir that changed clothes between afternoon and evening) global praise and worship standards like Shout to the Lord which was written by an Australian evangelical.

Evangelicals are masters of the global media and English is the linqua franca of large parts of the world.

Read the whole piece. How can Catholics of our generation respond besides saying "in three centuries they'll be gone and we'll still be here".

Comments?

4 Comments:

At July 6, 2007 2:51:00 PM MDT , Anonymous Stephen Sparrow said...

Last Sunday for the first time I attended a local Evangelical Protestant Service - after Mass at my own parish - the reason being we had staying with us a 23 year old female in-law relative and she wanted to attend her particular style church. Okay, I've seen snippets of this stuff on tv previously but you're right Sherry about the Prosperity Doctrine being preached - for 45 minutes - Kathryn was displeased I am pleased to report. The venue a tarted up warehouse was full and I guess half those present were young folk, curious young folk - I would say mostly young co-habiting couples there to try to figure out some purpose to life. Part way through the Pastor dedicated a three month old baby because "hey, this business of sprinkling water is a man-made thing." The rest of the service was a six piece band with two attractive female vocalists belting away. Didn't do much for me - I had to turn my hearing aids off but left them plugged in to ward off the effects of an overloaded accoustic environment.

 
At July 6, 2007 10:41:00 PM MDT , Anonymous Stephen Sparrow said...

Sherry you said, "How can Catholics of our generation respond besides saying "in three centuries they'll be gone and we'll still be here".

On further reflection of my visit to an Evangelical Church preaching the Doctrine of Prosperity, and looking around at the mixed bag of young people all looking for some direction, and this idiot Pastor in quite a clever almost insidious manner sows the seed that coming to his church is going to start them on the path to success - whatever that means; I'm predicting a massive fall off of interest as regular attendees wait in vain for the promised good things to start happening.

After the service, Kathryn said she would make her own way back to my place because she wanted to mingle a little. Two hours later one of the congregants gave her a lift which just happened to take her past the "fairly palacial pastor's home" which seemed to be another way to ram home the message of "hey look if you keep coming here this also can be yours."

Oh and yes I was very impressed with what the "stated" collection total was the previous week and looking around it just didn't add up.

So the problem is to pick these folk up after their first disenchanting brush with what masquerades as Christianity!

Well with God anything is possible....

Perhaps it might be a good idea to some time go to one of these services and see the subtle sort of propaganda practising Catholics are up against.

 
At July 7, 2007 4:16:00 AM MDT , Blogger Sherry W said...

Stephen:

The CT article was long and I almost missed this part but they point out that some "Prosperity" tinged preaching focuses on having enough (a gripping and seemingly miraculous prospect for those suffering from deep poverty) at a time in African society when many are experiencing new economic and educational opportunities.

Also, they refer to what I once heard called "the phenomena of redemption and lift" by evangelical missionary strategists. I,e., conversion changes character, priorities, and actions and so the future of families. If a man undergoes a conversion, stops drinking away all his income, returns to a renewed sense of devotion to his wife and children, and starts to hold a regular job - the whole family - benefits in very concrete ways, which are nevertheless a work of God.

So while some are disenchanted, there is enough reality to the whole thing to ensure that it isn't just going to vanish. And the next generation of leaders can react to abuses, correct them and start a new and healthier version.

Movements involving hundreds of millions of people don't vanish in a single generation or even several generations. Even when failing, it take centuries for something this large, deeply rooted, and vibrant to vanish.

We should grasp this by now since Protestantism isn't showing any signs of vanishing after 500 years of preaching less than full Christianity. It is changing its form and assumptions (classic main-line Protestantism is failing) but Reformation heritage Christianity (especially in its Pentecostalized forms) continues to grow and spread.

 
At July 7, 2007 10:42:00 AM MDT , Anonymous c matt said...

P t barnum would be proud. I don't know what could be done about it. People are always attracted to preaching that confirms what they want, etc. All I could suggest is emphasizing the best African preacher of all time, augustine. He nailed the problem of the prosperity gospel. It is using God to get things rather than using things to get closer to God.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home