Greetings from Latte land! (from your friendly University District Tully’s!)
Over at Catholic Sensibilities, the questions about who we are and what known movement we are related to or derivative of, keep coming in:
“How are your consults and programs at parishes different/same than the good ol’ Life in the Spirit seminars from the 70’s and 80’s? Renew from the 80’s and 90’s? Neocatechumenate Way from 2000? I’m just trying to understand where CSI and your term “intentional disciple” fit it to what has been done in US parishes since VII. Just trying to put you into a context.”
The short answer: we're not related to or derived from any of the above or the emerging Church movement or any other movement, for that matter. I'm a convert and so had no knowledge or experience of the Church until the late 80's and have never attended or been part of a Renew process in any way or the Neocatechumate in any way. Nor have I ever attended a Life in the Spirit seminar although I think I was asked to give a talk once at a seminar session but it never happened. Fr. Michael Sweeney, with whom I founded the Institute had no background in any of the above either.
The Institute arose out of a personal collaboration that began at Blessed Sacrament parish in Seattle between Fr. Michael (who was pastor) and myself (parishioner and grad student) in the mid 90's. Our primary Catholic influences were intellectual with a strong Dominican slant: Vatican II, John Paul II, St. Thomas Aquinas, Yves Congar, Josef Pieper, etc.
In my case, I brought my background at Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, CA and in the global evangelical missionary movement and the knowledge of the cutting edge stuff that passionately apostolic Christians are doing all over the world. Also, I'd created the gifts discernment process 3 1/2 years previously and had been offering it in the Seattle area and re-working and re-writing it as I went. While Fr. Michael, who is a cradle Catholic’s cradle Catholic, had been studying the theology of the laity and wrestling with the role of the parish in the mission of the Dominican order.
I can't explain it and it certainly wasn't part of anyone's plan or derived from another movement. It was just one of those spontaneous combustion God things. When Fr. Michael and I got together, intellectual and creative sparks flew. I suppose you could think of us as the theological and pastoral equivalent of Micky Rooney and Judy Garland saying "hey, gang, I know what we can do. Let's put on a show!" Or John Steed and Mrs. Peel (alas, I will never look like Diana Rigg in black leather :-\) - well, you get the idea . . .
Our purpose: To actually implement what the Second Vatican Council and the Church since has asked for in the area of the theology, evangelization, formation, and apostolic support of the laity. And to do it in the only place that 98% of lay Catholics have access to: the local parish. We weren't following any existing model because we didn't know of any that was parish-based.
The Called & Gifted process already existed and proved to be a wonderful popular vehicle to help spread the Church’s vision of the apostolic mission and authority of the laity.
It also enabled us to generate the income necessary to support the hand-to-mouth lifestyle to which we had become accustomed.
Our work is a lot closer to the explorations of Lewis and Clark than to that of Mapquest. People sometimes ask me what our 5 year plan is. I laugh and say that I have a two year guess. Because educated guesses are what you work from when you are exploring something new.
If you'd like to read the story of our beginnings, go here. It was written in the summer of 1997 just as the Institute began and so you can see what we were thinking at the very beginning.
9 Comments:
Speaking of Judy Garland, There is an a popular new group on Yahoo
called THE JUDY GARLAND EXPERIENCE. They feature amazingly rare audio
files, photo's, lively discussions, and more! The membership includes
people who knew Judy, authors of books on Judy, people who have
directed movies about her, longtime fans, new fans, and members of
Judy's family. The only thing missing from the group is you! Please
stop by and check it out.
http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/thejudygarlandexperience/
Well, from what I can gather, having experienced only some of the other movements, and only heard about yours .... You're effective, your program manages to point people to things that cause change and growth and maturity, if people are willing to follow the pointer you give them. It seems a lot are willing.
My experience of the movements (renew & small groups) is that they aren't really challenging, they're mostly social. And too much of the material was concerned with 'how do you feel" as I remember it. Except for the chance of adult conversation I thought a great deal of it was a waste.
When, in the cycle of responsibilities, I was in charge of the small group meeting, I started doing things like bringing in the Office of Reading reading for the day or the following Sunday because I hungered for some meat. One other member expressed appreciation - I wasn't the only one wanting stronger food than the small group materials out of the East Coast.
The official material and way of doing it was better than nothing, but it really didn't give us much to work with. Certainly didn't help us find our way in the world, that I noticed.
All but one in the parish are now defunct. I suspect because they weren't strong enough or helpful enough.
Or maybe their time has passed. shrug
I don't think you've been anywhere in my diocese, although you've been in SF and across the Bay. (Both just far enough that I don't quite make it to your presentation.) Maybe when some of those seminarians you recently worked with graduated and are out in the parishes I'll be in a parish where you'll be working. As I said, where I see CSI being different is you help people know how they can be more themselves, and in doing so bring Christ a little more into the world. It's more active than the other programs.
Peter wrote:
Secondly, in many cases, you will be coming into a parish that has bits and pieces of things (a Cursillo community, small Christian Communities, etc.) already in existence. It's easy to run the risk of being "one more thing" on the parish menu. My own parish held a CAG workshop a few years ago. It was a one-time thing and while I'm sure it had an impact on those who participated, I don't get a sense that the concepts really influenced the broader parish.
What I wonder is how the process of discernment of charisms and developing an understanding of the lay vocation can penetrate an entire parish and renew efforts at adult formation that are already underway, i.e. integrating these ideas into RCIA, small Christian communities, etc.
Peter, thanks again for participating in the discussions! We are very happy to have you here. You've managed to ask the $64,000 question in your comment.
My experience (and Sherry or Fr. Mike can back me up here) is that a parish that brings in a single C&G workshop and doesn't connect it with further discernment or with the work of formation of its members won't see a transformation of the community. It will remain an individual experience. Chances are, only those who perservere in the discernment process "alone" will begin to see actually understand their own personal mix of charisms.
In order for their to be community wide transformation, there generally needs to be a very intentional approach made by parish leadership or by individual parishioners who coordinate key programs. This intentionality often includes:
1. Buy in from the pastor and pastoral associate...not just verbally but by putting in to practice the discernment of charisms in their own lives and in their ministries. This often means fundamentally reorienting how ministries are 'run' both in finding and forming members.
2. An emphasis on formation for laity that isn't just focused on stuff happening inside the parish, but rather focused on mission to the world. This can happen both with formal opportunities (events, speakers, and programs) and during liturgical homilies, for example.
3. A committment to evangelizing parishioners (current and those 'missing members') as well as those new to the community.
4. Examining the overall strategic plan, as well as structures and processes of the parish so that they align with and foster the fundamental orientation toward mission.
among other things.
Although these steps generally need to happen, each parish is unique in both its gifts, mission, and history. So, how that all actually occurs will be quite different in each parish. It's interesting because I'm involved in another discussion online where this topic was broached.
Elaine,
Thanks for stopping by and sharing your thoughts and experience! What diocese are you in?
Hi, Peter;
I was a pastor at a parish that had a C&G about eight years ago - soon after the foundation of the Institute. I didn't realize what a profound vision of the Church and parish the workshop was going to introduce, and consequently didn't follow up with it. Nevertheless, some people's lives were profoundly transformed as a consequence of their discernment process after the workshop, including a periodontist who eventually left a lucrative practice to serve the dental needs of the homeless population in Eugene. She also started a minstry of healing prayer and is now studying to be a spiritual director. All from discerning her charisms!
We have a couple of resources that can help prepare a pastoral staff to respond more effectively to the workshop ("The Parish: Mission or Maintenance" and "Making Disciples, Equipping Apostles") Neither gives a step-by-step process, but they do present the challenge of the Church's vision for ministry in a parish.
Part of the challenge of implementation of that vision is we haven't seriously addressed the paradigm shifts required by the teachings of VCII. We tend to not focus on the needs of the secular society our parishes are supposed to address, nor are we evaluating whether our programs are actually bringing people into a deeper relationship with Christ that transforms the way they are in relationship with the people around them.
I can tell you that when I go back into parochial ministry, I know I'll have a very different approach - and it will be a tremendous, but exciting, challenge to implement what I've learned with the Institute.
Keith,
Diocese of San Jose. There are good people here, but of the ones I'm in contact with, there seems to be a hunger for more: More meat in the teaching areas and more guidance in living as Catholics in the world.
I only know lay people, BTW. And like calls to like and all that. Not everyone is hungering, but I get the impression there's a noticeable number of us.
Elaine,
Thanks! I will pray for your diocese and if I could, I'd like you to pray for the Archdiocese of Chicago.
I think if you hang out with lay people for any length of time, you will come into contact with that "hunger." It's a beautiful thing to encounter, but it can also be discouraging because in many situations this hunger is never satisfied at the parish level.
God bless!
Keith
I appreciate the recounting of this history. I might suggest that it would do the CIS some good to figure out where it does fit within the universe of Catholic lay movements and parish renewal programs that are out there.
I think this is good for two reasons. First of all, many of these movements also draw strength from a theology of the laity. You can see, for example, in the historical Cursillo material, many of the themes that are touched upon in Vatican II's Decree on the Apostolate of the Laity. While CIS is the result of some specific historical events, you are clearly part of a much larger historical movement. You need to understand your continuities with that tradition, both synchronically and diachronically.
Secondly, in many cases, you will be coming into a parish that has bits and pieces of things (a Cursillo community, small Christian Communities, etc.) already in existence. It's easy to run the risk of being "one more thing" on the parish menu. My own parish held a CAG workshop a few years ago. It was a one-time thing and while I'm sure it had an impact on those who participated, I don't get a sense that the concepts really influenced the broader parish.
What I wonder is how the process of discernment of charisms and developing an understanding of the lay vocation can penetrate an entire parish and renew efforts at adult formation that are already underway, i.e. integrating these ideas into RCIA, small Christian communities, etc.
If I was going to put this in computer terms, I'd say it's the difference between trying to get a parish to develop an entire new computer system or an application that can synthesize and maximize the effectiveness of existing "legacy systems."
I know that you are already thinking about and doing some of these things. But I thought I would offer the thoughts anyway.
Hi, Peter:
From a tiny computer erie at the top of Blessed Sacrament priory in Seattle.
You are asking the right questions which we have been wrestling with for years. Of course, since the Called & Gifted is the "seed" that we scatter as we go but it takes a much higher level of abiding conviction and determination on the party of leaders to change the course of a whole parish.
As Keith said, that why we offered Making Disciples - a four day training during the summer for pastoral leaders to expose them to the whole vision. Over the past 3 years, 200 diocesan and parish leaders have gone through. And what is really exciting is that increasingly, parish leaders are "getting it" and then going home and making it live.
Parishes do integrate and implement in very different ways depending upon the gifts and personality of their leadership, their unique situation and community, etc. Obviously, this is far too complicated to deal with in a comment.
Some of the parishes that have been influenced by us and are in various stages of implementing the vision(all in unique ways) would include
St. Dominic's, San Francisco (http://www.stdominics.org/)
Sacred Heart, Boise
(http://www.sacredheartboise.org/)
Holy Apostles, Colorado Springs (http://www.holyapostlescc.org/)
St. Mary's, Greenville, SC
(http://www.stmarysgvl.org/)
St. Patrick's and St. Francis Xavier, Spokane
(http://parishesonline.com/scripts/HostedSites/Org.asp?ID=14610}
Blessed Sacrament Church, Seattle
(http://www.blessed-sacrament.org/index.html)
Sherry Weddell
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home